Joachim Low's side were defeated 2-1 by the Azzurri, after a double by Mario Balotelli in the first half.
And the one-time Bayern man was quick to point the finger at Hummels after the final whistle.
“Today, [Antonio] Cassano acted him out,” Scholl told ARD. “He will never, never ever - and I'm sure about this - again make that mistake, but at such a high level these mistakes will be punished straight away. Today this was deadly."
The 41-year-old however, did conclude the interview by saying: “Hummels has had a great tournament.”
Italy will now play Spain in the final of Euro 2012 on Sunday July 1, kick-off at 20.45 CET.