• International
  • America (EN)‎
  • United Kingdom (EN)‎
  • India (EN)‎
  • Ireland (EN)‎
  • Malaysia (EN)‎
  • Singapore (EN)‎
  • Canada (EN)‎
  • Australia (EN)‎
  • Nigeria (EN)‎
  • Ghana (EN)‎
  • Kenya (EN)‎
  • South Africa (EN)‎
  • España (ES)‎
  • Argentina (ES)‎
  • Colombia (ES)‎
  • Chile (ES)‎
  • México (ES)‎
  • Peru (ES)‎
  • Italiano
  • Deutsch
  • Français
  • Brasil (PT)‎
  • Nederlands
  • Türkçe
  • Indonesia
  • 中文
  • 繁體中文
  • 한국어
  • 日本語
  • ภาษาไทย
  • Tiếng Việt
  • فارسی
  • العربية
  • المصرية
  • السعودية
Edition: International
  • Betting
  • Mobile
  • Phone App

Follow us on

Goal.com

Hi | My Account | Sign Out
Register or Sign In:
  • News
    • Football News
    • Football Previews
    • Football Transfer News
    • England Football News
    • Italy Football News
    • Spain Football News
    • Germany Football News
    • Champions League News
    • Europa League News
    • South America News
  • Editorials
    • All Editorials
    • Football Previews
    • Player Ratings
    • World Player Of The Week
    • Top 10s
    • Exclusive
    • English Editorials
    • Italian Editorials
    • Spanish Editorials
    • Teams Of The Week
    • Slideshows
    • The Dossier
    • Omar Momani: Cartoon of the Day
    • Goal.com @ Twitter
  • Live
    • Live Match Centre
    • Live Scores
    • Live Blog
  • Transfer Zone
    • Transfer Talk
    • Transfers LIVE!
    • Transfer News
    • Transfer Tables
    • The 10 Best January Signings
  • Clubs
    • Arsenal News
    • Chelsea News
    • Liverpool News
    • Manchester United News
    • Manchester City News
    • Tottenham News
    • AC Milan News
    • Inter News
    • Juventus News
    • Roma News
    • Lazio News
    • FC Barcelona News
    • Real Madrid News
    • Valencia News
    • Bayern Munich News
    • Borussia Dortmund News
    • PSG News
  • Europe
    • Europe Home
    • Europe News
    • England Home
    • England Table/Results
    • Italy Home
    • Italy Table/Results
    • Spain Home
    • Spain Table/Results
    • Germany Home
    • Germany Table/Results
    • Champions League Home
    • CL Fixtures/Results
    • Europa League Home
    • EL Fixtures/Results
    • Rest of Europe Home
    • Rest of Europe News
    • World Cup 2014 News
    • World Cup 2014 Fixtures/Results
  • Asia
    • Asia Home
    • Asia News
    • Asian Champions League Home
    • Asians in Europe
    • Australia Football News
    • China & Hong Kong Football News
    • Japan Football News
    • Korea Football News
    • India, South, Central Asia Football News
    • South East Asia Football News
    • West Asia Football News
  • Goal Rich List 2013
    • Video Countdown
  • Americas
    • South America Home
    • South America News
    • Brazil Home
    • Brazil Table/Results
    • Argentina Home
    • Argentina Table/Results
    • Libertadores Home
    • Libertadores Table/Results
    • Copa America Home
    • Copa America Table/Fixtures
    • USA Home
    • USA (MLS) Table/Results
    • Gold Cup Home
    • Gold Cup Tables/Results
  • Champions League
    • Champions League 2012-13 Home
    • Champions League 2012-13 News
    • Champions League Fixtures/Results
  • Europa League
    • Europa League 2012-13 Home
    • Europa League 2012-13 News
    • Europa League Fixtures/Results
  • World Cup
    • News
    • Qualifying Fixtures/Results
  • Video
    • La Liga News
    • Serie A News
    • Bundesliga News
    • Champions League News
    • Pick of South America
    • Best of Europe
    • Europa League News
    • Ligue 1 News
    • MLS News
    • SPL Goals
    • Goal Show
    • Youtube Channel
  • Editorial »
No joy, but truth at last: Hillsborough findings end desperate wait for justice

No joy, but truth at last: Hillsborough findings end desperate wait for justice

Latest Inter must not sack Andrea Stramaccioni if AC Milan win the derby Previous
Sep 12, 2012 4:05:00 PM

Hundreds of thousands of previously unseen documents related to the 1989 disaster have been released by an independent panel, heralding calls for a new inquest into the tragedy

COMMENT
By David Lynch

For 23 years they fought and were told to "let it go". For 23 years they tolerated the lies about the day their loved ones had died. For 23 years the accusations of a cover-up were dismissed by those who knew so little. But on Wednesday, the truth was finally out.

The families of the 96 people who were crushed to death at Hillsborough Stadium on April 15 1989 gained the one thing they had long craved at Liverpool's Anglican Cathedral this morning, as the Hillsborough Independent Panel released the results of its two-year inquiry.

Those tasked with compiling the report perused over 400,000 pages of previously withheld documents from 80 different organisations present that day – for the first time, nothing was denied them.

Yet, while the truth they sought has at long last been delivered, it is an unpalatable one; a stark exposure of an insidious process aimed at ensuring that the victims - men, women and children that they were - were blamed for their own deaths.

It is well known that this process began almost immediately, as chief superintendent David Duckenfield insisted that Gate C of the Leppings Lane end had been forced open by fans and not, as was later found, on his orders.

HILLSBOROUGH INQUIRY
ALL THE REACTION & COMMENT
  • Families finally learn shocking truth behind tragedy
  • Prime Minister 'profoundly sorry' - David Cameron's statement in full
  • Liverpool MP Rotheram demands accidental death verdict to be quashed
  • Sheffield Wednesday welcome release of Independent Panel's findings
  • Families of Hillsborough victims call for justice to follow the truth
  • Liverpool football club chiefs thank Independent Panel

But Wednesday's revelations provide harrowing evidence that this was just the tip of the iceberg; the officers present were already discussing the "animalistic behaviour" of "drunken marauding fans" in the immediate aftermath of 96 people dying. The tone, one of discrediting the dead, had been set.

This was not just callous disrespect for the deceased, but part of a wider plot aimed at shifting the blame, a ploy which had succeeded up until today. It gained further pace with the dissemination of false information to a leading Conservative MP, Irvine Patnick, who, rather than clarify whether these spurious accusations were true, took his concerns directly to the media, most notably the Sun newspaper.

The subsequent "The Truth" headline and the allegations that fans urinated on and picked the pockets of the dead have proved hard to shake, and played a large part in cementing the myths which those fighting for justice over Hillsborough have had to fight so hard to tear apart.

Meanwhile, as these lies were already being spread across the nation, the bodies of those who died were being tested for blood alcohol levels. When the results provided a negligible reading – one that didn't suit the story – the police then tasked themselves with finding a criminal record for that person.

If the authorities could not prove that drunkenness had caused the disaster, or the presence of a hooligan mob, then the blame could lie nowhere else than at their feet, and this is the desperate truth they wished to avoid.

The families perhaps expected they would get the opportunity to air these grievances as the inquests were held but, yet again, they were wronged. Dr. Stefan Popper's decision to impose a cut-off time of 3.15pm for all evidence (on the incorrect basis that all the victims had suffered irreversible injuries by that point) robbed the families of a true inquiry into the emergency services' inadequate response.

HILLSBOROUGH BIGGEST COVER UP IN BRITISH HISTORY
Get Adobe Flash player

The report has now proved that 41 of the 96 who died "potentially could have survived" beyond the cut-off point and that a staggering 31 of the victims had heart and lung function after that time had passed. Over half of the death toll dismissed as irrelevant to the original inquest, the truth that they could have been saved hidden for over 20 years.

Chillingly, even these sham inquests were originally deemed "unnecessary" by the man who eventually presided over them. Dr. Popper had argued that the cause of death for all of those who perished was already well known, seemingly ignoring the fact that to not hold them would be illegal.

The evidence provided by police has also now also come under scrutiny with the revelation - one which the families had long seen dismissed by observers - that 116 "negative comments" were removed from statements made by police present on the day.

Several of these did not point to any severe malpractice but rather highlighted the lack of planning and due care from the police which was undoubtedly the leading cause of the disaster.

All of these factors came together to deceive the public about what had happened that day but, unfortunately for those responsible, the people who had been present could not be fooled. Or silenced.

That it has taken 23 years to reach this epiphany should go down as a low point in British legal history, a miscarriage of justice which David Cameron has today hinted the Attorney General will right with a series of fresh inquests.

But there can be no joy devised from finding out such horrific truths.

Only the subsequent apologies, expected retributive action and an ability, 23 years long in the making, to finally lay the memory of those 96 innocent victims to rest, can provide a crumb of comfort.

Follow David Lynch on
Sign up with William Hill for a free bet up to £25 WilliamHill
Sign up with bet365 for a free bet up to £200 Bet365
Sign up to Paddy Power for £250 in free bets PaddyPower
Sign up today with Coral and get a £50 FREE bet - no strings attached! Coral
Sign up today with BetVictor and get a £25 FREE BET! BetVictor
  • Liverpool
Latest Inter must not sack Andrea Stramaccioni if AC Milan win the derby Previous

Related Stories

  • England»
    Liverpool thank Hillsborough Independent Panel for its report
  • England»
    Hillsborough inquiry: Liverpool MP Steve Rotheram demands accidental death verdict to be quashed
  • England»
    Hillsborough inquiry: Prime Minister 'profoundly sorry' - David Cameron's statement in full
play
open
play pause open close
Inside Goal.Com
  • Top Specials
  • Most Read
  • Most Discussed
  1. Ancelotti’s departure leaves PSG in a pickle Ancelotti’s departure leaves PSG in a pickle

    With the Italian bound for Spain, the Ligue 1 champions face an uncertain immediate future

  2. Cartoon: Bayern & Dortmund given licence to thrill Cartoon: Bayern & Dortmund given licence to thrill

    Goal.com cartoonist Omar Momani gives us his unique take on the football news of the day

  3. Soulless EPL must face up to grim reality Soulless EPL must face up to grim reality

    After a season marred by controversy and a failure of its top teams to put up a credible Champions League challenge, the world's supposed best league is falling behind

  4. La Liga awards for 2012-13 La Liga awards for 2012-13

    Goal crowns the best and worst from Spain over the course of the season

  5. Why Real Madrid are appointing Ancelotti Why Real Madrid are appointing Ancelotti

    After the decision to dispense with Jose Mourinho was announced on Monday, the Spanish side have set their sights on the PSG coach, and he looks like the ideal man for the job

 
  1. Mourinho to be Chelsea boss
  2. Madrid/Ancelotti a match made in heaven
  3. Jose Mourinho to leave Real Madrid
  4. Mou had to go & Real better without him
  5. Podolski: Joining Juve is conceivable
Goal.com International
  • News
  • Editorials
  • Live
  • Transfer Zone
  • Clubs
  • Europe
  • Asia
  • Goal Rich List 2013
  • Americas
  • Champions League
  • Europa League
  • World Cup
  • Video
Goal.Com Editions
  • International
  • America (EN)‎
  • United Kingdom (EN)‎
  • India (EN)‎
  • Ireland (EN)‎
  • Malaysia (EN)‎
  • Singapore (EN)‎
  • Canada (EN)‎
  • Australia (EN)‎
  • Nigeria (EN)‎
  • Ghana (EN)‎
  • Kenya (EN)‎
  • South Africa (EN)‎
  • España (ES)‎
  • Argentina (ES)‎
  • Colombia (ES)‎
  • Chile (ES)‎
  • México (ES)‎
  • Peru (ES)‎
  • Italiano
  • Deutsch
  • Français
  • Brasil (PT)‎
  • Nederlands
  • Türkçe
  • Indonesia
  • 中文
  • 繁體中文
  • 한국어
  • 日本語
  • ภาษาไทย
  • Tiếng Việt
  • فارسی
  • العربية
  • المصرية
  • السعودية
More
  • Betting
  • Mobile
  • Phone App
Copyright © 2013 Goal.com All rights reserved. The information contained in Goal.com may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without the prior written authority of Goal.com
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service| Contact Us| About Us