Carlo Ancelotti has picked the club captain to start in the UEFA Super Cup clash against Sevilla on Tuesday - and it could be make or break for the 33-year-old.
Benched by former Madrid boss Jose Mourinho at the peak of his powers, Casillas then suffered an injury and found himself as a reserve once again as the Portuguese moved to sign Lopez.
Madrid then announced late last May (on Casillas' birthday, ironically) that Mourinho would be leaving the Spanish side and Carlo Ancelotti was appointed as his replacement. Things were expected to return to normal.
But they didn't. Goalkeeping coach Villiam Vecchi chose Lopez to start in La Liga above Iker and the club captain was forced to wait until the cup competitions. And even that began badly as Casillas clashed with Sergio Ramos in a freak collision against Galatasaray in Istanbul which left the keeper sidelined once again.
Goalkeepers, however, are often remembered for their errors and Casillas' mistake in the Champions League final allowed Atletico's Diego Godin to score what was so nearly the winning goal. Luckily for Iker, however, Ramos headed home deep into added time to save his teammate and force extra-time. A grateful Casillas planted a kiss on the defender's forehead amid the celebrations and he later lifted the trophy as Madrid scored three more in the next 30 minutes.
But the keeper's luck ran out at the World Cup in a dreadful display against Netherlands. Spain was defending the title it won in 2010, but suffered a shock 5-1 reverse and Casillas was responsible for at least two of the goals.
Coach Vicente del Bosque kept faith in his skipper for the crucial clash against Chile, but he fared little better and his mistake gifted the South Americans a second goal and Spain was sent packing after just two games.
Back in club colors this summer, Casillas was found wanting once again in the 3-1 loss to Manchester United, arguably at fault for all three of the goals scored by Louis van Gaal's men.
Many madridistas, meanwhile, believe Iker was culpable for filtering tales of dressing-room discontent to the press during the Mourinho era via girlfriend Sara Carbonero and other contacts in the Madrid media. Booed by some supporters and attacked on social media, the last year has been anything but easy for the club captain.
And now, after having been persuaded to stay by sporting director Fernando Hierro and club president Florentino Perez earlier this summer, he faces another fight for the starting spot at Madrid.
"I haven't been at my best in the last few games for Real Madrid and Spain, but I have analyzed and learned from them," Casillas said on Monday ahead of his side's Super Cup clash. And he added: "The club has treated me very well, I have no complaints. I want to push myself even harder than last year."
Ancelotti, meanwhile, is behind his skipper - in public at least. "I have complete confidence in Casillas," he said.
"Iker is a great keeper who had a great season in the Champions League and he will have another fantastic season coming up. Everybody makes mistakes, it's totally normal - but you have to learn from them."
Asked if he had decided which of Casillas and Navas would start in La Liga, Ancelotti told the journalist: "I still don't know, and even if I did, I wouldn't tell you."
More mistakes on Tuesday, though, and it will be very difficult for the Italian to make an argument for Casillas to start as first choice in La Liga as well, with a rotation plan more likely and, unless he can return to the form of seasons gone by, even that is no guarantee.
Former Madrid goalkeeper Paco Buyo believes the arrival of Navas could help Casillas this term. "It's a good thing there is competition between the sticks," he told Goal. "Nobody has their place assured and when you have a team-mate who pushes you, who wants to play, who has great qualities, it helps you to prepare better and concentrate more. Competition is good for everyone."
But it also means the two must make their performances count and with La Liga's best goalkeeper from last season waiting in the wings, Iker will now have to prove himself over and over again for Real. Starting on Tuesday.
Follow Ben Hayward on