The profligate Italian is used to being the main man, but at Anfield the emphasis is on rotation and team play. Could his arrival throw off the Reds' attacking balance?
Television crews will be furiously scanning the Etihad crowd in search of the notorious manchild, whose on and off-pitch antics have forged both his icon status and his reputation as an atomic bomb always on the cusp of destruction. His rap sheet, not unfairly, tars him as a gamble, but it also threatens to hijack the discussion of his suitability to Liverpool, and the Italian’s arrival carries just as much risk on the pitch as off it.
The Merseysiders’ unexpected title charge last season was built on a frenzied, 100 mph attack that interchanged and dovetailed joyously, with Brendan Rodgers unshackling his side and granting his forwards enormous freedom – Balotelli, ironically, is more used to managers trying to reign him in than letting him off the leash.
MORE: Balotelli in photos | Done deals | WAGs
Although there is a very clear need to replace Luis Suarez in the attacking line — and some might say Liverpool has taken that particular modus operandi a little too literally by signing the equally controversial Balotelli — it is already obvious that the electrified Reds are an effervescent, dynamic attack even without the Uruguayan.
The bark may now be different, but the bite is very much the same; against Southampton, Daniel Sturridge and Raheem Sterling, the new "SAS" attack, both netted to elevate an otherwise mediocre team performance, showing predatory instincts and clinical finishing, while a week prior they dismantled a Borussia Dortmund side who would later beat Bayern Munich in the German Supercup.
The spark, even without the presence of a so-called marquee forward (though Sturridge would disagree), still exists and in fact Liverpool has rarely struggled without Suarez, with its win percentage increasing by 14 percent when the Uruguayan is not in the side — though admittedly its goals per game drops by 18 percent.
As such, tonight’s game lays down an important marker: a final glimpse of Liverpool before Balotelli is introduced to the lineup — the point after which he either adds to or hampers Liverpool’s attacking cohesion and fluency. Given his languid, stroppy style, which is virtually the antithesis of the Reds’ lightning-quick, rotating offense, initial fears are that he could be a hindrance — at least until he adapts.
Balotelli does things at his own pace, which is decidedly less intense than his new teammates are used to and far removed from the man he has been brought in to replace. Suarez led Liverpool’s off-the-ball pressing, he set the tone and tempo of their relentless waves of attacks, and he always looked to get on the ball and drive the side forward.
His Italian successor is far less conscious of his responsibilities when not in possession. He is more static — a fixed point of attack rather than a cog in an interchanging unit – and more prone to drifting out of games as his frustration turns to isolation, indifference and, more notably, flashes of rage.
It is a worry, too, that Balotelli needed almost twice as many shots from open play to score as Suarez did last season. Despite having outscored every other player in Serie A since making his Milan debut in January 2013, Balotelli’s strike rate is considerably more modest when penalties are removed – and it is unlikely that he will take over spot-kick duty while Steven Gerrard is still at Anfield.
Since the start of the 2012-13 season, Balotelli has netted just 13 goals from open play, with his tally heavily propped up by penalties and free kicks. Last season, he bagged just seven open-play goals, fewer than Sterling and new recruits Rickie Lambert and Adam Lallana managed.
Across the last two campaigns, his conversion rate from open play stands at a meager 8.3%, significantly less than both Suarez (20.3%) and Sturridge (24.7%). That chances-to-goal ratio would rank Balotelli 68th and last of any player who scored five or more goals from open play last season in the Premier League. It is worth adding the caveat, however, that Milan has struggled hugely in recent years and Balotelli only has been presented with a big chance every 255 minutes compared to 91 for Sturridge.
That could be either the cause or the result of Balotelli’s astonishing number of shots from outside the box. He may have scored more times from range (six) than any other player in Serie A – and his ability to produce something out of nothing should not be undersold – but he took an astonishing 94 shots from outside the box, producing just two goals from open play.
Of course, he may play that way because, as pointed out by his agent Mino Raiola, he was forced to carry a dire Milan side’s goalscoring burden almost singlehandedly last season, whereas he will no longer be a lone talisman at Liverpool. Yet there is a huge fear that Balotelli and specifically Sturridge cannot coexist – and getting the best out of the latter should have been a priority.
While the old SAS dynamic was a largely two-sided affair (Sturridge’s back-heel assist for his old partner against Cardiff won’t easily be forgotten), Suarez was always the more creative. He worked harder off the ball, he dropped deep, he played almost twice as many passes and he created an enormous amount of space for his teammates by committing defenders. Balotelli does not, nor does Sturridge.
It is still rare to see sides play with two strikers in the Premier League, which is largely why Liverpool scored so many goals last season, but Suarez was capable of being more than just a finisher to help counteract the shortcomings of playing two up top. Sturridge and Balotelli, though, two such like-minded players who thrive off the service of others and often contribute little beyond goals, are not.
There is little doubt that Balotelli has consistently flirted with world-class status, even if he’s never been quite as titanic as he was at the 2012 European Championships, but his signing presents Rodgers with a dilemma. Liverpool’s mesh of attacking venom, which swirls and swaps, could be diluted by the profligate Italian lone ranger, but equally he could bring the explosiveness and unpredictability it will miss in Suarez’s absence. For better or worse, that trade-off will begin after Monday’s trip to the Etihad.
Follow Ewan Roberts on