The Merseysiders' title hopes are left in tatters after a calamitous passage of defending at Crystal Palace ruined another outstanding attacking display.
Liverpool’s meltdown was so sudden, and Palace’s comeback so extraordinary, that all the emotions football can offer seemed to be squeezed into one bite-sized segment.
At the final whistle, the visiting players slumped to their knees en masse. A distraught Steven Gerrard, with tears gently rolling down his face, ushered the television cameras away, while Luis Suarez was bawling his eyes out so uncontrollably that he covered his face with his shirt and was led to the dressing room by unused substitute Kolo Toure.
By contrast, Palace’s raucous support celebrated with the unrestrained fervor that has been their trademark in a stunning turnaround under Tony Pulis’ wily leadership.
Selhurst Park bounced and rocked. Liverpool, which had penetrated, dominated and then crumbled, was in a state of shock.
The images provided a riveting footnote to what had been a loopy, bonkers and completely intoxicating chapter of play.
Cold analysis of this 3-3 classic will show that Liverpool’s dodgy defense let the club down after its effervescent attack had laid the foundation for what should have been a convincing victory that kept the pressure on title favorite Manchester City.
"Man City will go on and win it now," declared Brendan Rodgers at full time.
"For 75 minutes we were outstanding," he explained in a typically logical post-match assessment. "We scored three goals, we created many chances, then we conceded with 12 minutes to go and we have to see the game out better than that. You cannot come here against a very good side, be the threat that we were and then defend as we did. It is criminal really."
The frailties of Liverpool’s back five, evident even when the club was destroying teams during a remarkable 11-match winning run, were laid bare just when it seemed that they would once again be masked by more attacking brilliance.
Replays showed that the positioning and decision-making of Liverpool for all three of Palace’s goals were calamitous. The consequences were horrific, with substitute Dwight Gayle writing himself into Palace folklore with his deadly pair of side-footed finishes within a few pulsating minutes of one another.
Glen Johnson, a buccaneering asset to the Liverpool attack as the club romped into a three-goal lead, was made to look a novice as he showed a startling lack of awareness and resilience for each of the Palace goals. Martin Skrtel, who veers between the very good and the very bad with alarming regularity, and Mamadou Sakho looked like ham actors playing the fool in a 1920s silent movie.
Few could blame Gerrard, who had delivered a midfield masterclass for three-quarters of the match, or Suarez, who pilfered his 31st goal of the season, for their bitter disappointment. Both have expended so much emotional, as well as physical, energy in the bid to end Liverpool’s 24-year title drought.
Only hours earlier, Suarez had learned that he had added the Football Writers’ Association Player of the Year award to his PFA gong. The man he beat in second place in the journalists’ poll was his teammate and club captain.
The individual accolades will be a source of great pride but provide scant consolation as the events of the last nine days sink in.
Liverpool, which is one short of a remarkable century of league goals, has used its attacking strengths to compensate for sloppy defending all season. It has been a delicate balancing act, but one the team looked capable of winning. Yet, at the penultimate hurdle, it has fallen short.
|PALACE COMEBACK STUNS LIVERPOOL
ALL OF GOAL'S CONTENT
|REPORT: PALACE 3-3 LIVERPOOL|
|RATINGS: GAYLE THE HERO|
|POLL: TITLE RACE OVER?|
|GALLAGHER MOCKS TEARFUL SUAREZ|
|RODGERS CONCEDES TITLE|
|PULIS MUST WIN MANAGER AWARD|
"There is no doubt. Manchester City will go on and win it. We needed to win to keep the pressure on going into the last game and we did not do that. You have to have that maturity to see it through and we did not do that. It was bitterly disappointing and I would expect Manchester City to go on and win their two home games."
In this roller-coaster season, a victory for Aston Villa at City on Wednesday night is certainly not out of the question. Paul Lambert’s youthful counterattacking team is better on the road and has some big scalps to show for it.
Whether or not Liverpool gets the kind of assistance Palace gave City to open up the title race again, a more solid base is required at Anfield next season, when Champions League commitments will test a squad that needs considerable beefing up.
Daniel Agger should be sold if Rodgers feels he is too static and leisurely to play a major role, and at least two center backs and a fullback recruited to challenge Skrtel, Sakho and Johnson for a regular starting place.
Liverpool’s army of recruitment specialists need to have a better window than last summer, and prove they are as good at spotting defensive talent as they are at finding under-valued strikers and attacking midfielders.
There is a great deal to admire about this Liverpool team. It has provided some wonderful entertainment this season. But every title-winning side needs to have a solid foundation.