Fernando Torres, Andy Carroll and the 10 worst January transfer window signings by Premier League clubs

This month has failed to ignite and managers could be right to treat it with caution after looking at the New Year recruits who have struggled to adapt at new teams.

By Chris Davie and Jamie Dunn

EPL: Fernando Torres, Wigan  v Chelsea
Getty Images
January can be a time for the Premier League elite to strengthen for the final push towards the title and Champions League places, while clubs at the other end the table recruit personnel in order to stave off relegation.

Since its introduction in the 2002-03 season, we've seen the January transfer window allow teams to bolster their ranks with shrewd signings who have been able to prove their ability in the long term.

But for every success there is a failure and Goal.com takes a look at those who have been unable to inspire after being brought into the Premier League in January.

Jose Antonio Reyes | Sevilla to Arsenal (£17m, 2004)


Jose Antonio Reyes couldn’t have had a better start to his Arsenal career, winning the Premier League title within months of his transfer from Sevilla in January 2004.

But, despite winning and scoring in the 2004 Community Shield victory against Manchester United, Reyes failed to consistently hit top form in north London.

Reyes was on the winning side against United again in the FA Cup final in 2005 but was sent off in the game and, just over a year later, after complaining of being homesick, eventually joining Real Madrid in a loan exchange deal with Julio Baptista.

James Beattie | Southampton to Everton (£6m, 2005)


A striker who has enjoyed several prolific spells in his career, James Beattie has also had his fair share of barren runs throughout his career.

Beattie’s goalscoring exploits with Southampton earned him a move to Everton, but he would score just two goals following his move to Goodison Park in January 2005, and was sent off for a headbutt on Michael Essien against Chelsea just five games into his stay at the club.

Beattie would score 11 goals for Everton the following season, but struggled for goals in 2006-07 and was sold to Sheffield United, embarking on a good spell with the then-Championship side.

Jean-Alain Boumsong | Rangers to Newcastle (£8m, 2005)


Despite arriving at Rangers in summer of 2004 on a free transfer, Newcastle United boss Graeme Souness felt he'd seen enough promise to splash out 8 million pounds for the defender's services in the following transfer window.

Boumsong's first term in England started with promise but his second season was far from perfect, and with mistakes leading to goals becoming a frequent trait, the France international wasn't given the chance to atone for his mistakes and found himself sold to Juventus, which had just been relegated to Serie B.

Ricardo Rocha | Benfica to Tottenham (£3.3m, 2007)


Signed from Benfica in 2007 by Martin Jol, Ricardo Rocha was brought in at Tottenham to bolster the defensive options following an injury to Ledley King, but his slip against Arsenal in the League Cup semifinal second leg against Arsenal came in his first handful of games for the club.

Jol was soon replaced by Juande Ramos, though, while Rocha fell out of favor and didn’t play a single first-team game in his final season at the club, before being released in the summer of 2009.

Afonso Alves | Heerenveen to Middlesbrough (£12.7m, 2008)


Shipped in to sprinkle Brazilian flair along Teeside, Alfonso Alves entered the Premier League boasting a record befitting of any top European striker after netting 45 goals in 38 games for Dutch side Heerenveen.

But Alves failed to replicate the sparkle produced by fellow countryman Juninho during his time at the club, as well as his form in the Eredivisie, scoring just four goals as Middlesbrough slumped to relegation from the Premier League.

Boro got shot of the Brazilian striker in September 2009, but only managed to claw back 6 million pounds as he went to ply his trade for Qatari side Al-Sadd.

Ricardo Quaresma | Inter to Chelsea (Loan, 2009)


Brought in by Luiz Felipe Scolari to liven up Chelsea's midfield, the winger, who was awarded Serie A's 'Golden Bin' award in his inaugural season in Italy, fared no better in the Premier League.

The Portuguese midfielder failed to impress former Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho at Inter, cue the loan spell at Stamford Bridge which ended in a paltry five appearances and 97 minutes of uninspiring league football.

Wayne Bridge | Manchester City to West Ham (Loan, 2011)

In the club's bid to avoid relegation, West Ham owners David Sullivan and David Gold felt it necessary to bring in recruits to solidify the defense at Upton Park.

Enter Wayne Bridge, who, with a £90,000-a-week wage, couldn't save West Ham from relegation in the 15 Premier League games he featured in.

Andy Carroll | Newcastle to Liverpool (£35m, 2011)


It was difficult to understand why Newcastle United rejected bid worth 30 million pounds from Liverpool for Andy Carroll last year, but even further beyond comprehension was Kenny Dalglish's side re-entering negotiations and subsequently bringing the striker to Anfield for 35 million pounds.

With the signing of Stewart Downing (who has also failed to convince the red half of Merseyside) you would think Carroll's clear heading prowess would be used to devastating effect, boosting Liverpool into the Champions League places and beyond.

As it stands, Carroll looks like a square peg in a round hole, floundering as the ball is played into his feet 20 yards from goal, rather than to his head inside the six-yard box. Four goals in 24 appearances means either Carroll must adapt to intricate build-up play, or Liverpool needs to change its style to suit its record signing.

Benni McCarthy | Blackburn to West Ham (£2.5m, 2011)


After a largely successful spell with Blackburn Rovers, West Ham parted ways with around 2.5 million pounds for Benni McCarthy, who had fallen out of favor at Ewood Park following the excellent form of Roque Santa Cruz.

But McCarthy could not resurrect his Premier League career with the Hammers, who eventually terminated the South African’s contract for 1.5 million pounds – which still had 14 months to run – in April 2011, after 14 appearances and no goals.

The club’s vice chairman, Karen Brady, revealed the striker had struggled with weight gain and described the signing as a “big fat mistake”.

Fernando Torres | Liverpool to Chelsea (£50m, 2011)


Chelsea broke the bank to sign Fernando Torres on a dramatic deadline day in January 2011 in an attempt to keep its aim to retain the Premier League title alive.

But the Spain international could not replicate the performances that had looked set to make him a Liverpool legend upon his arrival at Stamford Bridge, scoring just once in 18 appearances last season.

Torres has since added a further four strikes and a red card in 23 games, and while the jury is still out on whether or not the striker can turn his Chelsea career around, Roman Abramovich has not received the immediate return on his outlay he would undoubtedly have expected.
Thank you for your comment!
Please enter your name
Please enter your location
Please share your comment!
Comments
180 Comments
 
Advertisement
play pause open close
Inside Goal.Com
  1. RANKINGS: Top three American players all have the week off RANKINGS: Top three American players all have the week off

    Clint Dempsey and Landon Donovan were both out of action but remain the top two names on the board.

  2. RIGG: Banega joins list of humorous self-inflicted soccer injuries RIGG: Banega joins list of humorous self-inflicted soccer injuries

    Professional soccer players injure themselves in a variety of darkly humorous and preventable ways. Banega, by forgetting the handbrake, joins an extensive list.

  3. COHEN: When is it time for Arsenal and Arsene Wenger to part ways? COHEN: When is it time for Arsenal and Arsene Wenger to part ways?

    Arsenal's Wenger and Chelsea's Andres Villas-Boas are on the hot seat, and people need to accept that Robbie Keane would rather play in a top league than MLS.

  4. ROSANO: Club America secures win emblematic of tight Clausura race ROSANO: Club America secures win emblematic of tight Clausura race

    Club America won at home for the first time since August, but coach Miguel Herrera acknowledged the need for improvement. Pachuca coach Efrain Flores lamented the tight result.

  5. FOX Soccer Plus free preview - EPL, UCL, Serie A and more FOX Soccer Plus free preview - EPL, UCL, Serie A and more

    Sign up for FOX Soccer Plus today for access to Premier League, Champions League, Serie A and over 600 exclusive events!

 
Advertisement
Advertisement