Diego Simeone has had some fortune on his side during that time, but the Argentine's remarkable record against his compatriot is much more than just luck and certainly no coincidence. So how has he done it?
Messi made hay against Atletico for many a year, netting 20 goals in his first 14 fixtures versus the Madrid side. But since Simeone's arrival, he has found himself halted and is now without a goal in his last five games against the Rojiblancos: 341 minutes in total.
The first of those was a 2-1 win for Barca at the Calderon in La Liga last season. Messi started, but barely threatened. One defense-splitting pass almost let in Cristian Tello, but Diego Godin was alert to cut out the danger, while Messi also sent a free-kick straight at Thibaut Courtois before suffering a recurrence of his thigh problem and departing after 67 minutes. In his absence, Barca actually improved and turned the game around with only 10 men on the pitch as Alexis Sanchez levelled and Gabi scored an own-goal.
The teams' next meeting was in the Spanish Supercopa, also at the Calderon. And as in the previous match, Messi was forced off with an injury - this time at the interval. While on the pitch, the Argentine played one clever pass through to Pedro and also fired a shot wide from the edge of the area. But that was about it. Neymar cancelled out David Villa's opener in the second half as the game ended 1-1.
In January, Simeone's side then frustrated Barca once again in another goalless game at the Calderon. Messi, recently recovered from the thigh injury which had seen him sidelined for most of November and December, was left on the bench by Gerardo Martino and introduced at halftime in place of Andres Iniesta. Productive in his 45-minute cameo, Leo left empty-handed in large part due to Courtois. The Belgian goalkeeper deflected one dangerous cross out for a corner and made a stunning save to repel a left-footed drive late on. Messi also headed wide and sent one precise pass through to Cesc Fabregas, who was quickly crowded out by Godin, Joao Miranda and Filipe Luis.
And in last week's Champions League quarterfinal first-leg at Camp Nou, the forward could consider himself unlucky as he was frustrated again by Atletico and, in particular, Courtois. The Belgian brilliantly saved a first half header from the Argentine and produced a stunning stop late in the game to keep out a goalbound free kick from the 26-year-old. Earlier on, Godin had timed a block to perfection after Messi found Iniesta all alone in the area, with the Spain midfielder looking odds on to score.
|MESSI PROBLEMS AGAINST ATLETICO
|Atletico 1-2 Barcelona
Atletico 1-1 Barcelona
Barcelona 0-0 Atletico
Atletico 0-0 Barcelona
Barcelona 1-1 Atletico
|May 12, 2013
Aug 21, 2013
Aug 29, 2013
Jan 11, 2014
April 1, 2014
|67 minutes, no goals
45 minutes, no goals
90 minutes, no goals
45 minutes, no goals
90 minutes, no goals
"Simeone has got the players playing with such commitment - he has made the team much stronger," former Atleti player and youth coach Quique Estebaranz told Goal. "The defense is a very strong unit and that comes through hard work. Simeone, with the way he manages the dressing room, has got these players fired up and playing for each other - that's their big secret."
Defending deep with discipline, organisation, maximum commitment, courage and, when necessary, foul play, the back four are supported by a midfield which squeezes the spaces between the two lines to minimize the through-balls and defense-splitting passes made in La Masia.
"Pressing from midfield is important," Estebaranz added. "They work extremely hard to close the spaces available to Messi. It's not just the defense, but a team effort with help from the midfielders to drop into those spaces and crowd him out."
Messi is therefore forced to drop deep or out wide to look for the ball and here his participation is automatically reduced. The Barca midfield, meanwhile, is made to resort to sideways passes or more speculative searching balls which are often mopped up comfortably by the Atleti defense.
And if all else fails, there is a last line of defense in the commanding figure of Courtois. "He is enjoying a fantastic moment," Estebaranz enthused. "He has been in wonderful form for two or three years now and he makes such a big difference to this team - let's hope he can stay much longer at Atletico."
Barca have long looked less comfortable against defensive sides and never relish a physical battle. Atletico, in the image of Simeone as a player, are ultra-competitive, extremely fit, hugely passionate and sometimes cynical, stretching the rules to the limit in order to stop rival teams.
"Teamwork is the key," former Atletico forward Veljko Paunovic told Goal. "Inside Atletico, things are working well and that's evident. It's the fruit of hard work, planning and organization over the last few years. Simeone is a great leader in charge of a great project."
He did warn his former club, however, that concentrating on Messi could hand opportunities to others, such as Neymar, who has scored both of Barca's goals against the capital club this term. "Messi hasn't been able to score because Atleti's defenders have been on top of him," he said. "But that reduces pressure and leaves spaces in other areas of the pitch for other Barcelona players to create dangerous situations and score - as Neymar has done."
So what will happen this time? "It's exciting to see what technical and tactical strategies both coaches come up with," Paunovic added, while Estebaranz said: "I'm expecting more of the same: a tight game just like the previous four. It's a clash of styles and it will be an incredible battle."
This time, though, with a place in the Champions League semifinals at stake, one of the Argentines will have the last laugh. So will it be Simeone or will it be Messi? The game of chess continues.
Follow Ben Hayward on