Was a spectator for the majority of the game until inexplicably pushing the Davies's cut-back into his own net when under little pressure. Could do nothing about Hull's second.
Forced off with an injury just after the hour mark but will be pleased with his performance on the whole. Assured on the left-hand side.
Had Boyd and Graham with which to contend on the right-hand side but still commanded the flank as his own. Really impressive performance so soon after signing a new contract.
Cool, calm and collected, a reassuring presence against the more aggressive Kaboul. Together they worked very well.
His first start in a number of weeks as he continues to struggle with a return to fitness but showed no signs of strain as he marshalled the back line as captain and played 120 minutes.
A dominant performance, especially in the first half. Made Tottenham tick and regain their composure when dispossessed. Still running at the final whistle.
Put Spurs ahead with a goal-of-the-season contender after 17 minutes, turning two defenders with sublime ease before hitting a sumptuous half-volley from the edge of the area. Was always looking for the ball, definitely the hosts' biggest threat.
Seems to really enjoy playing alongside the marauding Paulinho. They both took turns when it came to defending and attack, combining effortlessly.
Made a number of neat passes and runs from deep but, more often than not, failed to find Defoe with the final ball.
Perhaps struggling for scraps with the majority of the game taking place in the midfield but was more than willing to venture deeper in search of the ball.
Extremely lively, always open for the ball and willing to receive, but was too often forced back by a Hull side strong in the tackle. Seemed to fare much better when the visitors tired in extra time and looked the best that he has been since joining Spurs.
Could do nothing about Sigurdsson's opener and otherwise coped well in his first start of the season as Tottenham struggled to test him throughout.
Completely outfoxed for Tottneham's first goal but regained his composure and was often the first man on Defoe.
Made life difficult for Tottenham, with the hosts frustrated as the game entered its final stages. Netted what threatened to be the winner with a towering header.
Could have done better with handling Sigurdsson, despite the neat flick from the Spurs man, but otherwise kept Eriksen quiet.
Withdrawn after just half an hour. Could do little about Sigurdsson’s opener but was often found wanting by Eriksen and Defoe’s movement.
Not the most impressive of performances as he struggled with Paulinho and Dembele all game.
Was a tad quiet at times in the first half but, along with his team-mates, seemed to get a second wind from Hull's equaliser. Was key to their extra-time display as he kept Dembele quiet and fed Boyd.
Ahmed El Mohamady
Was very lively in the first half and could well have equalised soon after Hull went behind, only for Kaboul to pull off a superb last-gasp challenge, with Friedel planted to the spot. Faded from then on and missed the decisive penalty.
Very lively early doors but faded quickly. Picked up again after the break but struggled to assert himself from then on. Was often beaten to the ball by Walker.
Missed a glorious opportunity to break the deadlock inside five minutes, with only the offside flag saving his blushes. Battled hard with Kaboul from then on, often losing, before being withdrawn at half-time.
Worked hard for his team and was particularly impressive when linking midfield and attack late on in the game.
Came on for Naughton and was impressive, again, in an unfamiliar full-back role. However, was at fault for Hull's second goal, allowing McShane far too much time inside the area to head home.
Nearly won the game for Spurs in the final minute of added time soon after coming on and then equalised with a lovely turn and finish. Will be delighted with his performance.
Came on at half-time and nearly scored with his first touch. Hurried and harried and helped drag away defenders for Hull's fortunate equaliser but was otherwise fairly ineffectual.
A late second-half substitution. Had one chance in the second half of extra time but was otherwise fairly anonymous.
Came on for Bruce after 33 minutes but struggled out of position, albeit his effort was not lacking.