Had no chance with any of the goals but was otherwise fairly reliable. Commanded his area well and seemed assured between the sticks.
Constantly caught upfield as Arsenal targeted the wings as an area of weakness in the Black Cats' defence. Ozil profited from him sleeping when he ought to have been tracking his man for the opening goal.
Relished the battle with Giroud and gave as good as he got in the air. Came close to netting too, striking the crossbar with a well-timed header.
Another weak link in the back four, the new signing struggled to get to grips with the interchanging of positions in the Gunners' four-pronged attack.
Couldn't get into the game whatsoever. Looked to struggle with the intensity of the encounter which may be due to a lack of match fitness, as much as anything. Rarely offered the sort of offensive threat his side required on the wing.
Overrun in midfield by the likes of Ozil and Wilshere but stuck to his task manfully during the opening period. Was sacrificed at the break for goalscorer Gardner.
Anonymous throughout, the South Korean midfielder looked lost in the middle of the park. Poor opening display for his new club.
Could not handle the sheer pace of Walcott and was caught treading water on numerous occasions as the visitors looked to attack his flank at every opportunity.
Tried his best as stand-in captain but never really got the beating of Gibbs. Helped out Celustka when the contest became stretched. Won the penalty that got his side back into the game after a jinking run.
Was excellent for the hosts, held the ball up exceptionally and brought others into play to give his side the rest they deserved after spending the majority of time chasing the ball.
Proved a handful for the visitors' defence as he made runs into the channel and shielded the ball well as Di Canio's men looked to defend from the front. Was unlucky to see his strike chalked off after muscling his way through in the second half.
Was effectively deployed as a sweeper as he dictated the Gunners' rhythm in possession from his own 18-yard box. In terms of goalkeeping, a solid display with a good stop from Altidore's drive in particular. Had no chance with the penalty.
Was as dependable as ever in the first half, always first to any long ball and his passing into midfield was crisp. But his contribution to this match will be defined on a stupid lunge on Johnson which helped see the Black Cats draw level.
Looked slightly inhibited at first but slowly grew into the game. His controlled ball over the top led to the opening goal. Was caught out badly for the equaliser.
Recovered from an early setback to provide a typically combative display down the right. Helped Walcott double up on the struggling Colback to devastating effect at times, including his cross for Ramsey's first goal of the afternoon.
A rock at the heart of defence for Arsenal as he stood in for the ill Per Mertesacker with the minimum of fuss. Was dominant in the air and quick across the ground too. Was fortunate to avoid conceding after Altidore brushed past him after the break.
The subject of fierce criticism after a poor performance for England in midweek, the Gunners' prized prodigy appeared fired up from the minute go. His passing was excellent, as were his energetic runs from deep. Started out on the left but drifted everywhere to bamboozle the Sunderland defence.
A truly magnificent debut from the Gunners' record buy, he was a joy to watch. His passing, clever flicks and constant movement tormented the Black Cats back line, who could only stand and observe the diminutive schemer's artistry at work. Understandably grew tired as the game wore on.
Provided a wise head at the base of his side's midfield, allowing the creative triumvirate of Wilshere, Ramsey and Ozil to pull the strings further upfield. Put himself about as he constantly strived to win back possession. Was booked in the second half for trying too hard, however.
Kept his team ticking in midfield with intelligent passing, a high work rate and a determination to help out defensively. The club's star man so far this season sparkled again. Deserved his goals; dispatching both superbly in another wonderful display.
Took his goal with aplomb and led the line well, but sometimes was guilty of over-complicating in the final third with his passing and first touches sometimes off. To his credit, he created the third goal with a lovely round-the-corner pass.
Missed a series of first-half chances that would have put the game to bed from an early stage. His speed was too much for Colback to handle but needs to improve his end product on this evidence.
Was introduced at the interval and tucked away the penalty - his first task after arriving on the field - expertly. Otherwise, his only notable contribution was to go into the referee's notebook for hauling down the magnificent Ozil.
Had very little impact during his spell on the pitch as the Black Cats went all out for a route back into the game but did test Szczesny with a low strike.
Could not get involved as much as he would have liked when he entered the fray in the second half, as Di Canio went in search of goals.