Made some fine saves to deny Palacio and was also alive to deny Cassano early on. Guarin's shot went straight through his hands but he was good overall.
Responsible for a succession of interceptions and helped keep things solid at the back for the hosts.
Provided several dangerous crosses from the left, including one to set up the opening goal. Extremely solid at the back, too. Booked for free kick that led to equaliser.
Great block on Milito early on and was dogged throughout, making a number of timely clearances.
Great header to open the scoring, and also contributed to the defensive side of the game by winning the ball back on a number of occasions.
Solid display at the back and also played a couple of impressive passes.
Good outlet on the right and made some enterprising runs.
Ran through the Inter team at will at times. Was at the heart of everything that his side did going forward and directly created two goals. Great display.
Quiet but efficient display in the middle of the pitch. Booked for foul on Cassano.
Put in a number of tackles in the midfield and looked to launch attacks with a number of long balls. Also flashed a low effort past the post.
Made up for a horrendous miss in the first half with two goals after half-time. Looked at handful for an admittedly poor visiting defence.
Could do nothing about the goals, but did little else either. Gave away a free kick in the Atalanta area as Inter searched for an equaliser.
Another dismal night at the back for the beleaguered stopper. Looked troubled throughout and gave away a penalty.
Better than partner Silvestre, but was caught flat-footed for Atalanta's second.
Anonymous throughout and often left Silvestre and Juan unprotected, which is never a good idea. Poor.
Full of energy when attacking, as ever, but often exploited defensively with several chances being created down his side.
Not one of the Argentine's better nights as Atalanta strolled through the midfield all too often.
Did well to set up Palacio late on but didn't put in his usual tenacious display. Booked.
Inevitably sent a number of shots off target from long range, before coming up with a screamer to draw his side level. Played well on the whole and seemed to be the only Inter man who played with any urgency.
Caused the home defence problems with his direct running but did not have as much influence as he would have liked.
Fed off scraps all night and failed to get involved.
Saw two headers well saved by Consigli, but might feel he should have put away one of them. Got his goal eventually but it was too little, too late.