Is Van Gaal a risk worth taking for Manchester United?

The Dutchman has a history of controversies and fall-outs but his CV and ability to develop and build competitive sides is more impressive than any other manager on the market
By Ewan Roberts

On Wednesday morning, a new era will officially dawn at Manchester United.

With the curtain now long having closed on last season's dismal campaign at Old Trafford, the man chosen to bring the good times back to the club - Louis van Gaal - will walk through the doors of Carrington for the first time as manager.

With the unfamiliar misery and strife of the David Moyes era consigned firmly to the past, now the focus switches to what the club can expect from the definitive marmite manager, a man who has married controversy with glory in a career littered with as many fall-outs as titles.

Van Gaal's credentials and pedigree cannot be questioned. Everywhere the Dutchman has gone he has brought success, as seven league titles in three different countries, plus a Champions League victory, attests – as well as an unbeaten World Cup qualification campaign that saw an Oranje squad that had been embarrassed at Euro 2012 book their place in Brazil faster than any other European side.

The weight of Van Gaal's success, and the mentality he brings to every match, will be vitally important to a United group who seem to have lost the nous, know-how and confidence to win games. Moyes's greatest failing was that he allowed his own inherent pragmatism to erode the relentless will to win that had been etched into every United player by Sir Alex Ferguson over decades – and at an impossibly fast rate.

But Van Gaal can return United to a side that naturally assumes superiority, that looks to play with a swagger. Upon joining Bayern Munich, he remarked, "I am who I am: confident, arrogant, dominant, honest, hard-working and innovative." The qualities of the man are replicated in his teams, but also echo the traits that United sides of the past were noted for. Under Moyes, mediocrity was tolerated. Under Van Gaal, only perfection will do.

The first task presenting the new manager will be to overhaul the playing squad. The ageing back-line centre-back pairing of Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic have left and Patrice Evra looks close to departing, while there has not been a cerebral hub to the midfield since Paul Scholes hung up his boots, several of the most promising youngsters, such as Paul Pogba, were allowed to escape, and, incredibly, there are only two undisputed first-teamers in the prime age range of 25-28 - Wayne Rooney and Juan Mata.

But even those two players may find themselves victims of a manager who is deeply attached to a philosophy that the players must adapt to, not the other way round. Van Gaal generally plays 4-3-3 and not much else, which leaves little room for both Van Persie and Rooney, while Mata would need to reinvent himself as a deeper-lying playmaker.

It already has the makings of a messy dressing room political saga, and United could risk writing off the two biggest outlays of Moyes's ill-fated tenure, with Rooney having been handed a bumper new contract. Equally, Van Gaal will look to develop and work with whatever players he has at his disposal: "I'm a coach who wants to – and can – improve players."

Indeed, Van Gaal has already made his first marks on the club before his official arrival by approving big-money deals to bring Luke Shaw and Ander Herrera to Old Trafford, while Antonio Valencia is set to play a key role after being being handed a new three-year deal.

Unquestionably, though, it is a system that has worked incredibly well on the continent and can be credited with laying the foundations of much of Barcelona and Bayern's recent dominance. It was Van Gaal who began die Roten's transformation towards a possession-dominating outfit and blooded in many of the younger stars now performing key roles, such as Toni Kroos and Thomas Muller.

Even Bayern's current coach, Pep Guardiola, has been influenced by the Van Gaal way of playing. "My jaw dropped when I saw Van Gaal's Ajax play," says the Catalan. "They did everything a football team should do perfectly in my eyes."

Yet there is a nagging fear that Van Gaal is slightly behind the curve stylistically, which has been highlighted by his protege's Champions League exit. The merits of the 'tiki-taka' football Bayern Munich and Barcelona play has been re-evaluated of late as the reactionary, powerful football of Real Madrid and Atletico assumed dominance in La Liga and in the Champions League final.

That said, Van Gaal is not quite so dogmatically attached to possession football - and even says, if the chance presents itself, that long, direct balls forward are perfectly acceptable; Robin van Persie's stunning diving header against Spain is a perfect case in point.

5/1 Robin van Persie is 5/1 with bet365 to be top scorer this season
Yet how suitable is Van Gaal's style in the Premier League? English football is defined by its physicality and frenetic turnovers, and there is a clear fervour for frenzied waves of attack rather than patient build-up among British terraces. Brendan Rodgers, for example, quite quickly ditched his attempts to play possession football, and Liverpool's style is now defined by their speed and directness. How suitable, too, is this United squad to playing the way Van Gaal demands?

There must be reservations, too, as to whether Van Gaal is the right man to hand a £200 million summer warchest to. Would he build a side ripe for English football, and how well would it survive once he is gone?

Ultimately, the biggest fear is that the 62-year-old is too much of a renegade. His ballsy (literally) motivational tactics are well documented, but it is his demeanour in public that matters most. In the past he has been curt, brash and rude, but United – as a brand – need a figurehead that represents certain values. Moyes was too meek, defeatist and beleaguered, while Van Gaal goes almost too far in the opposite direction.

So the imminent arrival of Van Gaal presents an interesting trade off. On the one hand he has the pedigree, conviction and team-building skills United have been starved of, but on the other hand he is volatile and perhaps overly attached to a philosophy that is, at best, no longer in vogue, and, at worst, outdated.

But he presents the lure of a near-instant return to better days, and, even if his tenure ends in flames, as been the case previously, there is a sense that he could achieve a great deal no matter how brief his reign. And, of course, Old Trafford is no stranger to a fiery, temperamental presence in the dugout, and it has never done them any harm before.

Follow Ewan Roberts on