RSS
ATOM
advertisement
English Angle: He's No Cristiano Ronaldo, But Antonio Valencia Can Make It At Manchester United
He'll never win the Ballon d'Or, but that's not to say United won't keep winning the titles, writes Goal.com's Sulmaan Ahmad...
01-Jul-2009 6:25:21 PM
There's only one Ronaldo, and it's not the Portuguese winker, but what even his most vitriolic detractors must surely recognise is his outstanding individual ability cannot be replicated or replaced by another player on the planet.
Leo Messi may even be superior, but doesn't offer as many options as a forward and, as an adopted Catalan, is one of the few players that can still be considered truly untransferable in world football.
Who else can wreak so much havoc from either wing? Maybe Franck Ribery, but he is nowhere near the same goal-threat.
Who else can combine the pace, power, skill and goals? Kaka, yes, but he is not so effective from wide areas, nor is he on the market, having also found his way to the Bernabeu, alongside CR7 (or CR9, as it is speculated he will soon be known).
Sir Alex Ferguson, blanking one and all streams of speculation from the mass media, has not even considered 'replacing' Cristiano Ronaldo. Even names as big as Franck Ribery and Karim Benzema, though they may have ended up taking the No. 7 shirt, wouldn't have taken CR7's place.
It seems Fergie is adopting a much more low-key route towards rebuilding for life after Ronaldo. Luis Antonio Valencia was confirmed as the first signing of the summer just yesterday, for a rumoured £16m from Wigan Athletic.
This is on a par with Tottenham signing Wilson Palacios - also from Wigan - for £14m in January, a transfer universally criticised but ultimately vindicated, as the Honduras international hit the ground running at White Hart Lane and added an invaluable dimension to the Lilywhites' midfield.
The same can be expected of Valencia. Sir Alex appears to now be favouring the blueprint of his 1999 treble-winners. That was a team - despite the inclusion of Ronaldo's No. 7 predecessor, David Beckham - that was full of hard-workers and level heads. For all of Beckham's fame, he rarely made a scene with a strop quite like Ronaldo.
Valencia can slot in on one wing and develop into a top class player, but never will he be made a star. Like Carrick, like Anderson, even like Berbatov, he will be subject to squad rotation whenever Sir Alex sees fit, and serve as just one of many weapons in United's armoury. Their only guaranteed starter up front is Wayne Rooney, and even he can end up playing anywhere from centre-forward to either wing, whether he likes it or not.
You can guarantee that Fergie will have not once told Valencia he is Ronaldo's replacement. At least one more player will be signed by the Red Devils this summer as they seek to further substitute for the loss of their star man. Karim Benzema looks to have slipped through their fingers, as Real Madrid moved for the French prodigy after Valencia (that's the club, this time) refused to sell David Villa.
Next on Ferguson's list, if you believe what you read, is Sergio Aguero. Certainly, United could do a lot worse, and El Kun would certainly make a worthy heir to the No. 7. Then again, the least glamorous option, still rumoured to be under consideration at Old Trafford, is Klaas-Jan Huntelaar.
We can't quite even rule out the possibility of Ribery making the move to Old Trafford, although he, like Benzema, has a preference for the Spanish capital, if he is to be released from the clutches of the incredibly bullish Bayern hierarchy.
Whatever happens, replacing Cristiano Ronaldo will not be a simple, like-for-like swapping exercise. Valencia may not quite be in 'youngster' territory any more, but as he is approaching 24 years of age, still has several years ahead of him in which to improve, given the right coaching and the right team-mates. He couldn't ask for much better than Man United, and despite his relatively low profile, the test of time may reveal that United would have struggled to do too much better than Valencia.
After all, this is just the beginning...
Sulmaan Ahmad, Goal.com
Leo Messi may even be superior, but doesn't offer as many options as a forward and, as an adopted Catalan, is one of the few players that can still be considered truly untransferable in world football.
Who else can wreak so much havoc from either wing? Maybe Franck Ribery, but he is nowhere near the same goal-threat.
Who else can combine the pace, power, skill and goals? Kaka, yes, but he is not so effective from wide areas, nor is he on the market, having also found his way to the Bernabeu, alongside CR7 (or CR9, as it is speculated he will soon be known).
Sir Alex Ferguson, blanking one and all streams of speculation from the mass media, has not even considered 'replacing' Cristiano Ronaldo. Even names as big as Franck Ribery and Karim Benzema, though they may have ended up taking the No. 7 shirt, wouldn't have taken CR7's place.
It seems Fergie is adopting a much more low-key route towards rebuilding for life after Ronaldo. Luis Antonio Valencia was confirmed as the first signing of the summer just yesterday, for a rumoured £16m from Wigan Athletic.
This is on a par with Tottenham signing Wilson Palacios - also from Wigan - for £14m in January, a transfer universally criticised but ultimately vindicated, as the Honduras international hit the ground running at White Hart Lane and added an invaluable dimension to the Lilywhites' midfield.
The same can be expected of Valencia. Sir Alex appears to now be favouring the blueprint of his 1999 treble-winners. That was a team - despite the inclusion of Ronaldo's No. 7 predecessor, David Beckham - that was full of hard-workers and level heads. For all of Beckham's fame, he rarely made a scene with a strop quite like Ronaldo.
Valencia can slot in on one wing and develop into a top class player, but never will he be made a star. Like Carrick, like Anderson, even like Berbatov, he will be subject to squad rotation whenever Sir Alex sees fit, and serve as just one of many weapons in United's armoury. Their only guaranteed starter up front is Wayne Rooney, and even he can end up playing anywhere from centre-forward to either wing, whether he likes it or not.
You can guarantee that Fergie will have not once told Valencia he is Ronaldo's replacement. At least one more player will be signed by the Red Devils this summer as they seek to further substitute for the loss of their star man. Karim Benzema looks to have slipped through their fingers, as Real Madrid moved for the French prodigy after Valencia (that's the club, this time) refused to sell David Villa.
Next on Ferguson's list, if you believe what you read, is Sergio Aguero. Certainly, United could do a lot worse, and El Kun would certainly make a worthy heir to the No. 7. Then again, the least glamorous option, still rumoured to be under consideration at Old Trafford, is Klaas-Jan Huntelaar.
We can't quite even rule out the possibility of Ribery making the move to Old Trafford, although he, like Benzema, has a preference for the Spanish capital, if he is to be released from the clutches of the incredibly bullish Bayern hierarchy.
Whatever happens, replacing Cristiano Ronaldo will not be a simple, like-for-like swapping exercise. Valencia may not quite be in 'youngster' territory any more, but as he is approaching 24 years of age, still has several years ahead of him in which to improve, given the right coaching and the right team-mates. He couldn't ask for much better than Man United, and despite his relatively low profile, the test of time may reveal that United would have struggled to do too much better than Valencia.
After all, this is just the beginning...
Sulmaan Ahmad, Goal.com
Thank you for your comment!
Please enter your name
Please enter your location
Please share your comment!
2 Comments
Advertisement
Live!
Champions League Draw LIVE - Road To Munich!
Welcome to Goal.com's Live coverage of the draw for the knockout stages of the 2011-12 Champions League. Stay right here to find out who will be facing who, with the elite of European football now narrowed down to 16 competitors, all hoping to wrench the title from current champions Barcelona.
16/12/11
That concludes the Champions League draw, and an intriguing set of fixtures have been revealed. AC Milan v Arsenal and Napoli v Chelsea look to be the picks, but Bayer Leverkusen v Barcelona could also be a tie well worth watching.
16/12/11
Olympique Marseille v Inter
16/12/11
Zenit St Petersburg v Benfica
16/12/11
CSKA Moscow v Real Madrid
16/12/11
Bayer Leverkusen v Barcelona
The champions travel to Germany for their round of 16 match.
The champions travel to Germany for their round of 16 match.
Inside Goal.Com
-
Liverpool's Midfield Is Equally At Fault As Their Forward Line
Though the attention tends to lean on their misfiring forwards, Liverpool's midfielders are as much at fault for their team's current position...
-
Media shy, silently arrogant & irrationally stubborn: 5 reasons why Abramovich should not be a cry baby
Calm from the outside, cranky from the inside. Goal.com's Sarthak Dubey gives a few tips to Roman Abramovich on how to handle the club's sensitive confidence levels...
-
Can Luis Suarez repeat Eric Cantona's grand comeback when Liverpool face Manchester United?
The divisive Uruguayan can look to history when he starts against United on Saturday for the first time since receiving an eight-match ban for racially abusing Patrice Evra
-
Beware, Inter & Arsenal - Schalke's rise up Deloitte's Money League proves the financial importance of the CL
The Ruhr side's remarkable run in Europe's elite tournament saw their revenue unexpectedly soar last season, but some teams are structured to depend on such results to survive
-
This Week That Year - The Munich Tragedy that shocked the world of football
In yet another edition of This Week That Year, we look into all the historic footballing events in the first full week of February....
Advertisement
Advertisement