Roberto Mancini's side came from behind to grab a point against the Merseyside club, with Marouane Fellaini's opener for the away team cancelled out by the Argentine striker
David Moyes and his hard-working Toffees team proved to be Roberto Mancini’s bogeymen once again; the Italian manager has just one win against the Scot from seven encounters.
Everton had taken the lead in the first half through Marouane Fellaini before the goalscorer fouled Edin Dzeko inside the box, giving Carlos Tevez the chance to level the game from the spot just before the break.
Moyes named an unchanged team to the side that drew against Arsenal in mid-week, with Leighton Baines – a major doubt before the game – passed fit to start and Toffees talisman Fellaini lining up behind Nikica Jelavic.
Mancini rotated his expensively assembled squad, making four changes to the team that beat Wigan 2-0 on Wednesday night. Joleon Lescott came back into the side to face his former club, while Samir Nasri, Tevez and Dzeko also started.
Everton made the brighter start, showing more tempo than the home side in the early exchanges, with City’s technicians struggling to affect the game before briefly bursting into life mid-way through the first half; David Silva’s cross was deflected inches wide by Sylvan Distin before Nasri had a goal-bound shot blocked by the head of Dzeko.
But the Toffees were rewarded for their early endeavour in the 33rd minute. Baines, afforded too much space from deep, had time to swing in a brilliant far-post cross which was met with a powerful header by Fellaini. Joe Hart did brilliantly to stop the initial shot, but palmed the ball more up than out and the Belgian was able to tuck in the follow-up.
City mounted an energetic response, with Tevez flicking a header towards the back post that was well saved by Tim Howard before Nasri’s cross was chested down by Gareth Barry for Dzeko to blast towards goal.
From the resulting corner, Dzeko was unnecessarily manhandled by Fellaini, with referee Lee Probert pointing to the spot. Tevez stepped up, waited for Howard to dive to the right before passing the ball down the middle of the goal. Fellaini almost made amends before the half-time whistle, forcing Hart into a good low save after outjumping Vincent Kompany.
There was more energy and control to City’s play after the break, with the tenacious Tevez leading by example; but the Toffees, in typical Moyes fashion, defended resolutely and the Citizens struggled to carve out any clear-cut chances.
Mancini tried to rally his side with the introductions of Sergio Aguero and Mario Balotelli, but it was to little avail and it was the visitors who came closest to scoring. Kompany cynically ended a swift Toffees counter, and Hart was almost embarrassed by Jelavic’s resulting free-kick.
The draw hands City’s rivals United the chance to extend their lead at the top of the table when they face Reading later today, while Everton lose ground on the top four.