thumbnail Hello,
Debate: Should Nigeria pick Moses or Babatunde against Argentina?

Debate: Should Nigeria pick Moses or Babatunde against Argentina?

Getty Images

Should the Chelsea forward return to the starting XI for the crucial Group F match against Argentina or has the 21-year-old done enough to retain his place in the team?

DEBATE
By James Ezimoha & Solace Chukwu

Stephen Keshi pulled off a surprise with his team selection for Nigeria's 1-0 victory over Bosnia-Herzegovina, dropping Victor Moses, one of the team's high-profile players, and replacing him with Michael Babatunde.

The FC Volyn Lutsk man hadn't made much of an impact for the Super Eagles before this summer and was a surprise inclusion in the final squad of 23.

He impressed, however, against Bosnia, delivering an efficient, measured performance and providing the midfield with balance. Next up are Argentina, with Nigeria facing the opportunity to return to the last 16 for the first time since 1998. They must gain at least a point from their final group game to keep control of their own destiny with Iran still a threat to their progress should they manage to beat the Bosnians.

Two of Goal Nigeria's writers debate whether Babatunde should retain his spot in the first XI, or whether Moses should return to the team.

Moses is out of form - Babatunde should keep his place

By Solace Chukwu

Momentum is an important thing in football. Class may be permanent, but in World Cups it is form that often makes the difference.

For this reason, it would be a huge mistake for Victor Moses to return to the Super Eagles starting XI against Argentina.

The mercurial winger was horribly off the pace against Iran. So negligible was his impact that he only touched the ball 16 times and played six passes in 52 minutes.

Following Nigeria’s struggles in the opening group game, Stephen Keshi turned to a virtual unknown in Michael Babtunde - whose experience in the national side comprised of four anonymous appearances.

It was a tremendous show of faith in the 21-year-old, but he repaid it several times over. Confident on the ball and drifting intelligently out to the flanks to maintain width when the wingers moved into central positions, Babatunde exuded calm. He grew into a more direct goal threat in the second half, twice drawing saves from Asmir Begovic.

Dropping Moses was a big statement. But he had been running on auto-pilot, safe with his status as one of Keshi’s ‘undroppables’. This was to serve as a shock to the system required to get him motivated again.

So, has the lesson been learnt? There’s only one way to find out: play him.

However, consider the stakes here. The Super Eagles have not qualified yet, and travel to Porto Alegre on Wednesday needing a point to guarantee progression. Surely it is more of a risk restoring Moses - a player who spent virtually the entire league season on the bench?

The correct call is to retain Babatunde.

Follow Solace Chukwu on 

Argentina are not Bosnia - Moses must return

By James Ezimoha

Congratulations to Michael Babatunde for delivering a fantastic performance against Bosnia and Herzegovina. However, there is a big difference between starring versus Bosnia and then doing the same against Argentina.

Despite having a poor game against Iran in the first match, as the entire Nigeria team did, Victor Moses’ importance to the team cannot be questioned.

Time and again, the Chelsea man has almost single-handedly dragged the Super Eagles to victory, scoring and assisting vital goals.

This is the man who delivered Nigeria the African Cup of Nations 2013 and took them through the rigours of World Cup qualification.

In every area of the game - bar defending - Victor Moses outshines Babatunde, particularly in the final third.

Even against Bosnia, Babatunde's decision-making in and around the opposition box let him down so many times. He seldom took responsibility for attacks, opting to play safe. This attitude won't get you very far at the World Cup.

Moses on the other hand takes delight in driving at defenders, and almost always carries the attacking threat for the Eagles. So why would you leave such a player on the bench? A player who, unlike few others, has the experience of playing on the biggest stage against the best opponents.

Argentina are not Bosnia.

Babatunde is not Moses.

Follow James Ezimoha on 

Should Moses or Babatunde start against Argentina? Comment below and let us know.

Related

From the web