Our Man City correspondent Sam Lee takes on his Barcelona counterpart Ignasi Oliva as they try to pick a winner between the two ball-playing goalkeepers
Manchester City tried to sign Marc-Andre Ter Stegen this summer but ended up with Claudio Bravo.
Pep Guardiola wanted a ball-playing goalkeeper to help improve his new team and Bravo has impressed during his time at the Etihad Stadium so far.
But would he have been better off with Ter Stegen?
Our two dedicated club correspondents - City's Sam Lee and Barca's Ignasi Oliva - rated both keepers right from the heart of Camp Nou.
Watch their discussion below and see if you agree with their decision.