|
|
Danny Welbeck, Javier Hernandez or Dimitar Berbatov - who should partner Wayne Rooney in crucial Manchester United clash with Liverpool?
Chicharito came off the bench to hand Sir Alex Ferguson's side a point against Chelsea on Sunday, and gave the Scot a selection headache ahead of fierce derby game
10 Feb 2012 08:13:00
Getty Images
DEBATE
When Javier Hernandez came off the bench to head Manchester United level with Chelsea on Sunday, the Mexican striker handed Sir Alex Ferguson a selection headache ahead of the clash with bitter rivals Liverpool.
The Scot opted to start with Wayne Rooney and Danny Welbeck at Stamford Bridge but watched as his team fell three goals behind Andre Villas-Boas' side.
But, after Rooney had scored two penalties, Chicharito stooped in to score the all-important equaliser in the 84th minute.
Welbeck was far from anonymous against Chelsea though, winning one of the spot kicks during the second-half comeback, while at times Rooney looked at his very best as United pursued a foothold in the game, and must now be a near-automatic choice to face Liverpool.
And United also have another striker in Dimitar Berbatov who has proven pedigree against Kenny Dalglish's side, so Ferguson has plenty of attractive options to choose from regarding who should partner the England international ahead of the clash at Old Trafford.
Jon Birchall | UK Live Editor
When Rooney came on as a substitute in Manchester United's last Premier League game against Liverpool, the 1-1 draw in October, the striker entered the pitch subdued and never looked like making an impact. Hit by the blow of his three-match Euro 2012 ban only days earlier, he sullenly watched the game pass him by from midfield.
Played in a similarly deep position in matches against the likes of Otelul Galati and Everton in November, Sir Alex reacted to his side's 6-1 humiliation at the hands of Manchester City by reeling his most dangerous player in and hoping for goals to come from elsewhere.
That Rooney is expected to be so versatile pays testament to his skill as a footballer, but evidence suggests that it is alone where he proves himself most effective in front of goal. The 2009-10 season, with Carlos Tevez and Cristiano Ronaldo having left the club and Javier Hernandez yet to arrive, saw the forward tasked with playing a lone frontman role. With 34 goals in all competitions, it remains his most successful campaign by a distance.
It simply betrays the striker's natural instincts to play second fiddle to others on his team. Indeed, Rooney's willingness to work for his colleagues is refreshing as it is highly-lauded, but it is in front of goal where his predatory nature is most suited.
The timing is ideal for the former Everton man to be given the freedom of the forward line, with Ashley Young and Nani both returning from injury battling for a place on the left flank, and Antonio Valencia, in his finest form for the club since breaking his ankle against Rangers in September 2010 and so often Rooney's ideal foil, controlling the right.
United may be at home on Saturday but have arguably found Liverpool a more challenging attacking threat than any other side save for Barcelona and Manchester City in the last 12 months. With Luis Suarez, Craig Bellamy and Stewart Downing all providing devastating pace down the flanks, the hosts will need the likes of Valencia to negate their influence by dropping into a midfield five on occasion.
And grabbing the goals? Rooney has already proven time and again that he's more than up to the task.
Stephen Darwin | UK Assistant Editor
Statistics don’t win football matches but if Wayne Rooney's record alongside Danny Welbeck is anything to go by then Sir Alex Ferguson should look no further than to pick the England international strike duo against Liverpool on Saturday.
In just 10 Premier League starts this season the pair have tallied an impressive 16 goals between them, as well as five assists - a record unrivalled by any other strike pairing at the club - if not the league.
Rooney’s tenacity and vigour, along with his undoubted natural ability, makes him the perfect compliment for the pacy Welbeck.
The former Sunderland loanee, meanwhile, is more than happy to do the running while his international compatriot pulls the strings with the ball at his feet.
With three in his last five Welbeck is certainly not short of form, while Rooney’s role as primary conductor in the comeback draw with Chelsea last weekend should ensure he is raring to fly out of the blocks – especially given the mutual ill-feeling shared between the former Everton man and Saturday’s visitors to Old Trafford.
Whatever central defensive combination Kenny Dalglish decides to go with, the movement and interplay involving Rooney and Welbeck should cause ample problems for the likes of Martin Skrtel and Daniel Agger.
The pairing of Rooney and Welbeck would surely present Sir Alex Ferguson with a decent platform to take, as will be expected by the United faithful, all three points.
Chris Myson | UK Assistant Editor
After his side somehow came back from three goals down to draw 3-3 with Chelsea at Stamford Bridge, Sir Alex Ferguson admitted he probably should have started Javier Hernandez in attack alongside Wayne Rooney.
Hailing the Mexican striker’s movement and positional play, the manager praised him for changing the game and putting huge pressure on home defenders David Luiz and Gary Cahill, which eventually resulted in him heading the equaliser.
So far this season Chicharito is yet to reproduce the remarkable heights we witnessed in his debut campaign in England, with form, fitness and emergence of others all serving as obstacles in his path to success.
However, Hernandez is now showing signs he is returning to his energetic and prolific best and proved in the second half of last season that he can score consistently in the biggest games as well as compliment Rooney nicely.
While Danny Welbeck has had a strong campaign, Sir Alex should now revert back to his tried and trusted strike-force of last year’s title-winning team, as he admitted he should have done against the Blues last weekend.
The combination of the movement of Hernandez and Rooney’s creativity is likely to cause the likes of Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel – stoppers not renowned for impressive mobility - big problems on the day.
Chicharito scored at Anfield earlier in the season, as well as netting against Liverpool in the last campaign. In a vitally important game that may be decided by the finest of margins, United need to have one of the league’s top finishers on the pitch, rather than the bench.
Greg Stobart | Goal.com Correspondent
Dimitar Berbatov has cast a glum figure on the Manchester United bench this season but the Bulgarian will have happy memories of playing against Liverpool.
It was last September that Berbatov stole the show with a wonderful hat-trick - including a stunning overhead kick - in United’s 3-2 win over Liverpool at Old Trafford.
When Kenny Dalglish made an emotional return as Liverpool manager in January, Berbatov was the man who won the penalty - somewhat contentiously - that sent United into the fourth round of the FA Cup.
The reasonable conclusion can be reached from those two games at Old Trafford last season that Liverpool defenders find it tough to combat Berbatov’s touch, technique and skill.
Berbatov also has the touch of class - more so than Welbeck or Chicharito - to score a goal out of nothing in tight games.
And, despite featuring in only ten league games for the Old Trafford club this season - including five appearances as a substitute - the Bulgarian has still managed to score seven goals this season, including six in three games against Fulham, Wigan Athletic and Blackburn Rovers.
With Berbatov and Wayne Rooney providing creativity and goal threat centrally, United will be able to dominate possession and bring the best out of wingers Antonio Valencia and Nani, or the fit-again Ashley Young.
Starting Berbatov will also give Sir Alex Ferguson the chance of bringing Welbeck or Chicharito on in the second-half.
The Mexican, in particular, is razor sharp in front of goal and his pace and finishing ability could provide the knockout punch, as it did in securing a come from behind draw with Chelsea last on Sunday.
When Javier Hernandez came off the bench to head Manchester United level with Chelsea on Sunday, the Mexican striker handed Sir Alex Ferguson a selection headache ahead of the clash with bitter rivals Liverpool.
|
Sign up with 188BET for a FREE bet up to £25 – Great Prices, Every Game |
|
Open an account with Sportingbet today and get up to £50 in free bets! |
|
Sign up with William Hill for a free bet up to £25 |
|
Sign up with bet365 for a free bet up to £200 |
|
Sign up with Paddy Power - Bet £10, Get £20! |
The Scot opted to start with Wayne Rooney and Danny Welbeck at Stamford Bridge but watched as his team fell three goals behind Andre Villas-Boas' side.
But, after Rooney had scored two penalties, Chicharito stooped in to score the all-important equaliser in the 84th minute.
Welbeck was far from anonymous against Chelsea though, winning one of the spot kicks during the second-half comeback, while at times Rooney looked at his very best as United pursued a foothold in the game, and must now be a near-automatic choice to face Liverpool.
And United also have another striker in Dimitar Berbatov who has proven pedigree against Kenny Dalglish's side, so Ferguson has plenty of attractive options to choose from regarding who should partner the England international ahead of the clash at Old Trafford.
| ROONEY THE LONE STRIKER |
Jon Birchall | UK Live Editor
When Rooney came on as a substitute in Manchester United's last Premier League game against Liverpool, the 1-1 draw in October, the striker entered the pitch subdued and never looked like making an impact. Hit by the blow of his three-match Euro 2012 ban only days earlier, he sullenly watched the game pass him by from midfield.
Played in a similarly deep position in matches against the likes of Otelul Galati and Everton in November, Sir Alex reacted to his side's 6-1 humiliation at the hands of Manchester City by reeling his most dangerous player in and hoping for goals to come from elsewhere.
| TWO GOALS IN 15 GAMES |
|
|
|
|
| ROONEY'S UNITED RECORD VS LIVERPOOL |
|
| GAMES PLAYED GOALS SCORED WINS DEFEATS DRAWS |
15 2 8 5 2 |
It simply betrays the striker's natural instincts to play second fiddle to others on his team. Indeed, Rooney's willingness to work for his colleagues is refreshing as it is highly-lauded, but it is in front of goal where his predatory nature is most suited.
The timing is ideal for the former Everton man to be given the freedom of the forward line, with Ashley Young and Nani both returning from injury battling for a place on the left flank, and Antonio Valencia, in his finest form for the club since breaking his ankle against Rangers in September 2010 and so often Rooney's ideal foil, controlling the right.
United may be at home on Saturday but have arguably found Liverpool a more challenging attacking threat than any other side save for Barcelona and Manchester City in the last 12 months. With Luis Suarez, Craig Bellamy and Stewart Downing all providing devastating pace down the flanks, the hosts will need the likes of Valencia to negate their influence by dropping into a midfield five on occasion.
And grabbing the goals? Rooney has already proven time and again that he's more than up to the task.
| DANNY WELBECK |
Stephen Darwin | UK Assistant Editor
Statistics don’t win football matches but if Wayne Rooney's record alongside Danny Welbeck is anything to go by then Sir Alex Ferguson should look no further than to pick the England international strike duo against Liverpool on Saturday.
| THE DREAM TEAM |
|||
 |
|||
|
PARTNERSHIP
Rooney/Welbeck Rooney/Hernandez Berbatov/Hernandez Welbeck/Hernandez |
STARTS
10
7 4 1 |
GOALS
16
9 7 0 |
ASSISTS 5
1 1 1 |
Rooney’s tenacity and vigour, along with his undoubted natural ability, makes him the perfect compliment for the pacy Welbeck.
The former Sunderland loanee, meanwhile, is more than happy to do the running while his international compatriot pulls the strings with the ball at his feet.
With three in his last five Welbeck is certainly not short of form, while Rooney’s role as primary conductor in the comeback draw with Chelsea last weekend should ensure he is raring to fly out of the blocks – especially given the mutual ill-feeling shared between the former Everton man and Saturday’s visitors to Old Trafford.
Whatever central defensive combination Kenny Dalglish decides to go with, the movement and interplay involving Rooney and Welbeck should cause ample problems for the likes of Martin Skrtel and Daniel Agger.
The pairing of Rooney and Welbeck would surely present Sir Alex Ferguson with a decent platform to take, as will be expected by the United faithful, all three points.
| JAVIER HERNANDEZ |
Chris Myson | UK Assistant Editor
After his side somehow came back from three goals down to draw 3-3 with Chelsea at Stamford Bridge, Sir Alex Ferguson admitted he probably should have started Javier Hernandez in attack alongside Wayne Rooney.
Hailing the Mexican striker’s movement and positional play, the manager praised him for changing the game and putting huge pressure on home defenders David Luiz and Gary Cahill, which eventually resulted in him heading the equaliser.
| 'I SHOULD'VE CHOSEN CHICHARITO' |
 Sir Alex Ferguson after Manchester United's 3-3 draw against Chelsea:"To be honest with you I perhaps should have played Chicharito from the start as when he came on he had the Chelsea defence under pressure with his movement and positional play. "Danny [Welbeck] was terrific and is going to be a top player but when Chicharito came on in the second half, it was a different game." |
However, Hernandez is now showing signs he is returning to his energetic and prolific best and proved in the second half of last season that he can score consistently in the biggest games as well as compliment Rooney nicely.
While Danny Welbeck has had a strong campaign, Sir Alex should now revert back to his tried and trusted strike-force of last year’s title-winning team, as he admitted he should have done against the Blues last weekend.
The combination of the movement of Hernandez and Rooney’s creativity is likely to cause the likes of Daniel Agger and Martin Skrtel – stoppers not renowned for impressive mobility - big problems on the day.
Chicharito scored at Anfield earlier in the season, as well as netting against Liverpool in the last campaign. In a vitally important game that may be decided by the finest of margins, United need to have one of the league’s top finishers on the pitch, rather than the bench.
| DIMITAR BERBATOV |
Greg Stobart | Goal.com Correspondent
Dimitar Berbatov has cast a glum figure on the Manchester United bench this season but the Bulgarian will have happy memories of playing against Liverpool.
| BRILLIANT BERBATOV BAGS HAT-TRICK |
|
|
|
|
| FROM OUR LIVE COMMENTARY | |
| 85' | GOAL!! BERBATOV COMPLETES HIS HAT-TRICK!! 3-2 TO UNITED!! Scholes plays the ball out wide to O'Shea on the right and continues his run into the area. O'Shea's right-footed cross escapes Macheda but picks out the head of Berbatov, who rises above Carragher to thump home a header into the bottom left-hand corner. |
| PLAYER RATING |
|
| 9.5 | Did not simply maintain his outstanding early season but surpassed it. Three goals of differing but serious quality - two headers either side of a magnificently imaginative and impudent overhead kick. |
When Kenny Dalglish made an emotional return as Liverpool manager in January, Berbatov was the man who won the penalty - somewhat contentiously - that sent United into the fourth round of the FA Cup.
The reasonable conclusion can be reached from those two games at Old Trafford last season that Liverpool defenders find it tough to combat Berbatov’s touch, technique and skill.
Berbatov also has the touch of class - more so than Welbeck or Chicharito - to score a goal out of nothing in tight games.
And, despite featuring in only ten league games for the Old Trafford club this season - including five appearances as a substitute - the Bulgarian has still managed to score seven goals this season, including six in three games against Fulham, Wigan Athletic and Blackburn Rovers.
With Berbatov and Wayne Rooney providing creativity and goal threat centrally, United will be able to dominate possession and bring the best out of wingers Antonio Valencia and Nani, or the fit-again Ashley Young.
Starting Berbatov will also give Sir Alex Ferguson the chance of bringing Welbeck or Chicharito on in the second-half.
The Mexican, in particular, is razor sharp in front of goal and his pace and finishing ability could provide the knockout punch, as it did in securing a come from behind draw with Chelsea last on Sunday.
HAVE YOUR SAY
Who do you think Sir Alex Ferguson should play up front from the start against Liverpool at Old Trafford on Saturday?
Vote for your choice in our poll below, or if you think Manchester United should adopt an alternative approach, leave a comment.
Vote for your choice in our poll below, or if you think Manchester United should adopt an alternative approach, leave a comment.
| Sign up with 188BET for a FREE bet up to £25 – Great Prices, Every Game |
|
| Open an account with Sportingbet today and get up to £50 in free bets! |
|
| Sign up with William Hill for a free bet up to £25 |
|
| Sign up with bet365 for a free bet up to £200 |
|
| Sign up with Paddy Power - Bet £10, Get £20! |
|
Goal.com Poll
Poll runs from 10 Feb 2012 to 11 Feb 2012
Poll runs from 10 Feb 2012 to 11 Feb 2012
Who should start up front for Manchester United against Liverpool?
Rooney & Javier Hernandez
47.91%
Rooney & Danny Welbeck
24.57%
Rooney & Dimitar Berbatov
21.2%
Somebody else
3.2%
Rooney on his own
3.12%
Inside Goal.Com
-
Welbeck convinces Hodgson he is the man to lead the line
England beat Norway 1-0 at Wembley, with the Manchester United man hitting an impressive winner to stake his claim for a starting spot at Euro 2012
-
How England player's chances were affected by Belgium victory
Ashley Young all but secured his place in the starting line-up against France while captain Steven Gerrard put a good shift in. Joe Hart, however, needs to remain focused
-
Poll: Who should have replaced Cahill in the England squad?
Martin Kelly has replaced Cahill in the Three Lions squad going to Poland and Ukraine, but would Rio Ferdinand or Micah Richards have been more deserving?
-
Cartoon: Terry & Cahill add to England's injury concerns
Goal.com cartoonist Omar Momani gives us his unique take on the football news of the day...
-
In Pictures: The best and worst kits at Euro 2012
The European Championship is just around the corner and Goal.com distinguishes between the trendy and the passe at the prestigious tournament
