Played
February 4, 2012 7:45 PM EST
AAMI Park — Melbourne
Referee:‬ J. Gillett‎
Attendance:‬ 26395‎
 

Match report: Melbourne Heart 0 Melbourne Victory 0

Melbourne Heart claim the lion's share of the chances, but were forced to settle for a 0-0 draw with city rivals Victory.

By Bren O'Brien

A-League - Melbourne Victory - Melbourne Heart - Fabio - Rutger Worm
Getty

The winless A-League streaks of both Melbourne Heart and Melbourne Victory have rolled on after a lacklustre city derby which ended 0-0 at AAMI Park.

It is the second time this season the Melbourne derby has ended in a stalemate, with Heart dominating the first half of Saturday's match and Victory the second. But neither side was able to score the goal which would give them a crucial three points.

The result did greatest damage to Victory's finals hopes as they remain stranded outside the top six after a fifth-straight match without a win and a third consecutive draw. But having had to see out the final 15 minutes with just ten men after Grant Brebner was sent off, they will feel some relief.

A seventh-straight match without a win leaves Heart completely bereft of momentum and just five points in front of seventh-placed Newcastle, who could move closer with a good result against Sydney on Sunday. They had two great chances to win it late, but found luck and Ante Covic in their path.

It was a less than frenetic start to the game, with Heart dominating play and creating the better play, with Covic called onto punch away an early corner before Rutger Worm fired over after a good build up on 11 minutes.

Jonatan Germano was unlucky not to give his side the lead on 13 minutes, when his close-range header came off the bar with Covic beaten, after Eli Babalj had flicked on.

Victory's only chance of the first 30 minutes came from an error on a rare time the Heart were caught out in their own defensive half. Leigh Broxham fed Jean Carlos Solorzano, but the Costa Rican's shot slid wide.

Solorzano was afforded another chance in similar circumstances later in the half with the same outcome.

Heart midfielder Kristian Sarkies showed his noted dead-ball skills, forcing Covic into a brilliant save from a free kick on 26 minutes.

Debutant Craig Goodwin was the most impressive player on the park in the first 45 minutes, which as much an indication of the dis-jointed build up play of both sides as much as his adaptability to the A-League.  

Chastened by coach Jim Magilton, Victory looked vastly improved after the break, pushing forward and creating chances, including one for Harry Kewell, who shot over.

Solorzano remained the man most likely to score for them and after putting another shot just wide, he finally got the ball into the net only to be foiled by the offside flag.

The game had opened up significantly, and while Heart had a chance from Rutger Worm well saved by Covic, Bolton was the busier of the two goalkeepers and he watched Thompson and substitute Danny Allsopp shoot over soon after the hour.

But Brebner's dismissal on 75 minutes - a straight red for a studs-up challenge on Babalj - turned the momentum back Heart's way.

Sarkies should have punished Victory for a terrible defensive error when put through on Covic by David Williams but shot over, while on 80 minutes Goodwin almost capped a sensational debut with a wonderful goal, denied by Covic's outstretched hand.

Heart laid siege to the Yarra end goal in the final five minutes, but could not find a way through, with Michael Marrone coming closest with an effort which flew inches wide.



Melbourne Heart

1
Bolton
Goalkeeper
-
2
Michael Marrone
Defender
-
4
Simon Colosimo
Defender
-
18
Curtis Good
Defender
-
7
Rutger Worm
Midfielder
70′
-
8
Kristian Sarkies
Midfielder
-
10
Wayne Shroj
Midfielder
30′ 78′
-
13
Jonathan Germano
Midfielder
-
-
Craig Goodwin
Midfielder
-
11
Alex Terra
Striker
69′
-
19
Eli Babalj
Striker
-

Melbourne Victory

-
21
Ante Covic
Goalkeeper
-
3
Fabinho
Defender
-
4
Petar Franjic
Defender
-
4
Mark Milligan
Defender
-
23
Adrian Leijer
Defender
-
6
Leigh Broxham
Midfielder
-
8
Grant Brebner
Midfielder
35′ 74′
-
11
Marco Rojas
Midfielder
-
22
Harry Kewell
Midfielder
61′
-
-
-
10

Substitutes

-
Sebastian Mattei
Goalkeeper
-
3
Brendan Hamill
Defender
-
11
Paul Reid
Midfielder
78′
-
15
-

Substitutes

-
1
Tando Velaphi
Goalkeeper
-
-
Rodrigo Vargas
Defender
-
16
Carlos Hernández
Midfielder
71′
-
18

Coach/Manager

Coach/Manager

-
-
 
  • Goal
  • Own Goal
  • Penalty
  • Penalty Missed
  • Yellow Card
  • Assist
  • Penalty Save
  • Penalty Shootout Goal
  • Penalty Shootout Miss
  • Yellow Card / Red Card
  • Red Card
  • Substitution IN
  • Substitution OUT
  • Injury
  • Goal.com Rating
  • Goal.com Man of the Match
  • Goal.com Flop of the Match
  • Top & Flop Global Ranking
  • Fans' Man of the Match
  • Fans' Flop of the Match
Results
 
Top Scorers
Player   Goals Penalties
Besart Berisha Besart Berisha
Striker
Brisbane
21 1
Shane Smeltz Shane Smeltz
Striker
Perth
17 3
Carlos Hernández Carlos Hernández
Midfielder
Melbourne Victory
10 3
Mitch  Nichols Mitch Nichols
Midfielder
Brisbane
10 1
Ryan Alan Griffiths Ryan Alan Griffiths
Striker
Newcastle Jets
9 1